The Central Board of Secondary Education (CBSE) has approached the Supreme Court seeking recall of its September 28 order exempting Class VI students from the three-language policy for the current academic year, stating that the relief would apply to less than 1% of Standard VI students across CBSE schools in the country.
In its application filed on Wednesday, the Board said that of over 2.344 million students in Standard VI of CBSE schools, 99.82% (over 2.340 million) are already studying two native languages. According to the Board, the exemption would benefit 4,186 students nationwide (about 0.18%) who are studying two foreign languages. Additional solicitor general Aishwarya Bhati, appearing for the Centre, told a bench headed by Chief Justice of India Surya Kant on Thursday that the matter requires some "ironing out" and sought an early hearing; the court agreed to hear it next week.
The September 28 order had said that since the exemption is already available to students of Classes VII, VIII and IX, the same "comfort" should be extended to Class VI students. It was passed despite the Centre telling the court that 98-99% of schools have adequate facilities for the third-language policy and only 1.2% are yet to provide them.
The CBSE said schools affiliated to it have offered two native languages in Classes VI to VIII for decades, and that the third-language concept was introduced in Standard IX for the first time this year. Relying on its data, the Board said the perception that schools teaching foreign languages lack facilities for native languages is "wrong," and that relaxation for 4,186 students would be unfair to approximately 45,000 students who opted for two native languages in Class VI this year. The petitions challenging the policy were filed by students and parents of CBSE schools.
