The Delhi High Court has held that courts cannot require foreign nationals accused of visa violations to remain in detention centres as a condition for bail, saying such a direction would defeat the purpose of granting bail.
In a verdict delivered on Wednesday, a bench of justices Navin Chawla and Arun Bhardwaj said reasonable conditions may instead be imposed, including restrictions on movement, stipulations on place of residence and periodic reporting, depending on the gravity of the offence and the risk of the accused absconding or evading trial. The court observed that confining a foreign national to a detention centre would frustrate the bail order itself and hence cannot be imposed.
The bench made the observation while considering a reference from a trial court judge in a bail application filed by a Nigerian national accused of overstaying his tourist visa. According to the original story, the accused entered India in 2016 on a three-month visa but continued to reside in the country after it expired. The trial court had sought clarification on whether bail in such cases would effectively allow foreign nationals to stay in India without valid visas, and whether they could instead be directed to remain in detention centres during trial.
The High Court held that granting bail does not legalise an accused's continued stay in India or act as a substitute for a valid visa. It added that the law does not permit discrimination between foreign and Indian nationals in the matter of bail, while allowing courts to impose different conditions to ensure a foreign national accused is available for trial.
