The Delhi high court on Tuesday granted former chief minister Arvind Kejriwal and five other Aam Aadmi Party (AAP) leaders a last opportunity to file their responses in a criminal contempt case initiated by Justice Swarana Kanta Sharma over allegedly defamatory social media posts.
A bench of Justices Navin Chawla and Arun Bhardwaj cited the registry's report to state that all relevant documents had been served on Kejriwal, Manish Sisodia, Sanjay Singh, Saurabh Bharadwaj, Vinay Mishra and Durgesh Pathak, and asked them to file their replies within three weeks. The bench said the leaders could raise any grievance about non-supply of documents in their replies. "All the papers have been served. Now you file your reply in three weeks. Otherwise, we will close your right. Last opportunity," the bench said, after lawyers for the AAP leaders submitted that some documents had not been provided. There was no immediate response from the AAP leaders or the party.
The proceedings followed a face-off between Justice Sharma and Kejriwal that began on February 27, when a trial court discharged Kejriwal and others in the excise policy case and directed departmental action against a Central Bureau of Investigation officer. On March 9, Justice Sharma stayed the direction for action and deferred Enforcement Directorate (ED) proceedings in the matter. Kejriwal sought transfer of the matter from her bench, but Chief Justice DK Upadhyaya rejected the plea on March 13. On April 5, the AAP leaders sought Justice Sharma's recusal, which she dismissed on April 20. On April 27, Kejriwal informed the judge that he would boycott the proceedings, and Sisodia and Pathak subsequently wrote similar letters. On May 5, the court decided to appoint senior advocates as amicus curiae to represent the three leaders, but the matter was deferred. Justice Sharma initiated contempt proceedings on May 14 and later recused herself, saying the law did not permit a judge who had initiated contempt proceedings over allegedly defamatory, contemptuous and vilifying social media material targeting her to continue hearing the case.
Lawyer Ashok Chaitanya also sought contempt action against Kejriwal, Bharadwaj, Gopal Rai and a journalist, alleging a coordinated campaign targeting Justice Sharma. On September 21, the high court granted the AAP leaders four weeks to file their responses and allowed them to approach the judicial registrar for copies of documents and other material forming the basis of the contempt proceedings that had not been provided to them.
