The Delhi High Court has ruled that the Income Tax Department cannot tax a Mauritius-based investor's gains from selling equity mutual-fund units by treating them as gains from the sale of the underlying Indian shares. A bench of Justices Subramonium Prasad and Renu Bhatnagar, in its 17 November judgment, decided the case in favour of Emerging India Focus Funds, settling a ₹593.48 crore tax dispute over the treatment of such gains under the India-Mauritius tax treaty.

The court rejected the department's argument that gains from mutual-fund units should be treated as gains from the sale of the Indian shares held by those funds. It held that the fund owned mutual-fund units, not shares in the Indian companies held by the mutual funds, and that a unit holder of a mutual fund is not a shareholder of the company. The treaty, the court noted, specifically covers gains from the sale of shares and does not permit the department to look through mutual-fund units to the shares held by the fund.

For assessment year 2022-23, Emerging India Focus Funds, a Mauritius-based company registered as a foreign institutional investor with Sebi, reported ₹593.48 crore in capital gains from selling units of equity-oriented mutual funds and claimed the gains were not taxable in India under the India-Mauritius Double Taxation Avoidance Agreement. The tax officer treated 65% of the gain, or ₹385.76 crore, as taxable, and the Dispute Resolution Panel held the entire ₹593.48 crore was taxable. The Income Tax Appellate Tribunal ruled in favour of the fund in June 2025, and the department challenged that decision before the high court, which upheld the tribunal's view.