The Kerala High Court on Tuesday dismissed a plea by a lawyer from the prosecution team in the 2017 actress assault case seeking contempt action against the trial judge, holding that such proceedings cannot be initiated on the basis of hearsay or media reports. The court also asked the media to bear in mind that oral observations made by judges and lawyers should not be treated as news, particularly when their publication could hurt a party.
Justice P V Kunhikrishnan dismissed the plea filed by lawyer T B Mini, who had also sought the expunction of remarks allegedly made against her by trial judge Honey M Varghese, saying there was no evidence to establish that the judicial officer had made any defamatory remarks. The court said the allegations were based on hearsay and media reports, and that no evidence showed the judge had made any defamatory observations against the lawyer. It observed that it could not initiate contempt proceedings against a judicial officer based on the petitioner's hearsay version of an alleged statement made in open court, which was not in official records.
The High Court said judges speak through their judgments and that courtroom dialogue may sometimes be necessary to decide a case or persuade a lawyer to advance arguments. It said it was improper for the media to report such exchanges in a manner that tarnished the image of either, and advised members of the Bar not to be swayed by social media reactions merely because a judge made certain observations in open court with good intentions. It added that lawyers deserve dignity and fair treatment, and should not leave court after arguing a case feeling insulted or humiliated.
The court said the response of the Bar and the media should be guided by professional solidarity, restraint and mutual respect rather than the impulse to share, and expressed confidence that the media would continue to uphold journalistic principles. The sessions court had, on December 12 last year, sentenced six persons to 20 years in prison for gang rape, while actor Dileep and three other accused were acquitted. The case relates to the abduction and sexual assault of a multilingual actress inside a moving vehicle while she was travelling from Thrissur to Kochi on February 17, 2017.
