The Supreme Court on Friday dismissed Tamil Nadu's application seeking directions to Karnataka to immediately release an alleged backlog of over 11.7 thousand million cubic feet (TMC) of Cauvery water. A bench of justices Vikram Nath and Aparesh Kumar Singh rejected the plea, with Justice Nath remarking that the state appeared to have "lots of money to waste on lawyers" after it filed yet another application in the decades-old inter-state river dispute.
Tamil Nadu had sought directions to Karnataka to clear the alleged shortfall accumulated up to October 6 by releasing 1.3 TMC of water a day for 10 days at Billigundulu, the key measuring station on the Karnataka-Tamil Nadu border. The bench noted that Tamil Nadu had moved another application on Friday seeking fresh directions against Karnataka, and said it was inclined to dismiss that plea as well, following which Tamil Nadu's lawyer requested an adjournment on the fresh application.
In its rejected application, Tamil Nadu pegged the shortfall in flows at Billigundulu at 11.719 TMC up to October 6, arguing that Karnataka owed it the outstanding quantity even after accounting for the reduced allocation during the current distress year. It contended that Karnataka was withholding water despite having a combined reservoir storage of around 49 TMC, which it insisted was adequate to meet its obligations, and accused the Cauvery Water Management Authority and the Cauvery Water Regulation Committee of failing to direct Karnataka to make good the accumulated shortfall.
Karnataka opposed the plea, arguing that several districts in the state were facing drought and that its irrigation allocations had been reduced accordingly. It maintained that the water-sharing mechanism through the CWMA and CWRC was already addressing the issue and did not warrant further judicial intervention. Under the Supreme Court's water-sharing verdict, Karnataka must release 177 TMC of Cauvery water to Tamil Nadu in a normal year, with the allocation reduced proportionately in years of distress.
