Sonia Gandhi's memoir Belonging: A Journey of Love offers a candid account of the cultural barriers she faced after moving from a small Italian village to India's premier political household in 1968, according to a review of the book. The reviewer, an author of biographies on Mirza Ghalib and Adi Shankaracharya, notes that while the book was predictable to draw political controversy given her public profile, its most interesting aspect is her account of adjusting to Indian culture and adopting India as her home.
The review argues that the idea of a seamless "global village" is a fashionable truism among globalisation's advocates. Shared consumer habits—the same fast-food chains, denim and news networks across New Delhi, Tokyo, Nairobi and New York—do not erase deep civilisational differences in language, dress, customs, etiquette, religious beliefs and food preferences, it says. Culture, the reviewer writes, is not a coat to be slipped on and off at an airport counter.
Gandhi's memoir, the review says, strips away romanticised notions of effortless assimilation. She describes the vulnerability of being an outsider—feeling watched, anxious about unintended faux pas and grappling with what she terms the "unstated dictates" of an intricate Indian family structure. From adapting to fiery Indian spices and learning to wear a sari to agonising over how to address her mother-in-law, Indira Gandhi—resisting the expectation to call her "Ma" because, in her Italian soul, there could only ever be one Mamma—her account underscores how deeply ingrained cultural instincts resist overnight transformation.
Even after more than half a century in India and rising to the pinnacle of its public life, the review says, her reflections show that true belonging is never an automatic gift of globalisation but a slow and often painful negotiation with an alien civilisational grammar. The reviewer cites a humorous but true story from his own book, Becoming Indian: The Unfinished Revolution of Culture and Identity, of an Indian woman bureaucrat in Paris who set off a hotel alarm while trying to sight the moon for her Karva Chauth fast, and could not explain herself to the French police.
