A two-judge Supreme Court Bench hearing the suo motu case on the proposed relocation of the Central Secretariat Library (CSL) in New Delhi recused itself on Friday, saying the matter would be placed before Chief Justice of India Surya Kant for listing before the appropriate Bench, Bar and Bench reported. Justices PV Sanjay Kumar and Sanjeev Sachdeva cited recent decisions by the CJI that PIL cases pending before Benches without jurisdiction to hear them would be reassigned according to the court's roster. The Bench noted that although the CJI's office had been informed it had taken up the matter, it did not have the roster jurisdiction to hear the subject. Justice Kumar said, "Therefore, let the matter be placed before the CJI for listing before the appropriate bench," and made an indirect reference to the withdrawal of certain cases from a Bench headed by Justice Ahsanuddin Amanullah, adding, "Let's follow the procedure. You know what happened recently." The Bench said that even if the case were assigned to it again, it would not hear it until the CJI decided on its allocation.
The development comes amid a controversy over the reassignment of cases by CJI Surya Kant, who recently ordered the transfer of certain cases from Benches that did not have jurisdiction to hear PILs under the Supreme Court's roster, following concerns over Benches converting individual disputes into wider public interest litigation proceedings. Under the roster, PILs are assigned exclusively to Benches headed by the seven senior-most judges. The CJI's role as 'master of the roster' gives him the administrative authority to allocate cases and decide which Benches hear them.
The case concerns the 135-year-old CSL in Shastri Bhawan, which is proposed to be relocated as part of the Central Vista redevelopment plan to reportedly two rooms in the Kartavya Bhawan-2 complex. The library, housed at Shastri Bhawan since 1969 and spread across four floors, has roughly 8.5 lakh books, with no adequate arrangements made for their upkeep. The Bench initiated suo motu proceedings after The Indian Express published a report in October highlighting concerns over the proposed relocation and the lack of adequate arrangements at the new site. The library, under the Union Ministry of Culture, was originally set up as the Imperial Secretariat Library in Calcutta in 1891. As Shastri Bhawan is slated for demolition, the Culture Ministry requested around 5,466 square metres of space, but the Directorate of Estates under the Ministry of Housing and Urban Affairs proposed only two rooms spanning approximately 300 square metres at Kartavya Bhawan-2. In February, the Culture Ministry conveyed that the proposed space would not be sufficient for the entire collection and the library's facilities.
Amid concerns about the preservation of the books, the Supreme Court took suo motu cognisance after the matter was brought to its attention by some retired judges. During a hearing on November 16, the Centre assured the Court that the books would not be moved before the next hearing, scheduled for November 20, and the Court expressed concern over the proposed shifting arrangements, saying the government needed to show greater respect for the books. With the matter now referred to CJI Surya Kant, the next step will be to determine which Bench will hear the case.
